Thongchai Thailand

Archive for December 2021

CLIMATE ALARMISM OF THE DAY: LINK: https://www.express.co.uk/news/science/1535845/archaeology-future-climate-change-evg

PART-1: WHAT THE ARTICLE SAYS

Dec 14, 2021: Archaeology: How the study’s future involves helping to understand climate change. ARCHAEOLOGY may be recognised for helping to solve mysteries of the past – but did you know it’s now informing us about how humans could navigate the challenge of climate change? Britain’s Pompeii: Archaeologists excavate Bronze Age settlement. Tutankhamen’s tomb, Machu Picchu and China’s terracotta warriors are all examples of remnants from the past that archaeologists have helped to uncover. The study has existed for more than a century, and now looks poised to turn its attention from the past to the future, and help to contribute to discussions on climate change. For the first time, physical evidence of a Roman crucifixion in Britain was unearthed last week, by researchers who were investigating land due to be built on by a housing development. A ‘once in a lifetime’ discovery of a Bronze Age Axe was also made, in November. The study is evolving in more than one way. In fact, one of the key developments it’s making is in relation to climate change – but how is this possible? Here is how archaeology will help us to understand climate change. He explained how archaeology is capable of these changes because it’s a “contemporary subject”. Archaeologist Neil Redfern says “If you think about archaeology, we normally study stuff that’s been lost or deliberately thrown away or has suffered some catastrophe. We study the process of loss. Well actually that makes us understand why things fail. Today, archaeologists use a range of technology to assist ongoing excavations. So, it gives us a really good set of questions to start posing to society today about what the impact of climate change is going to be and what the impact of societal changes are going to be. What we do is we try to use evidence of the totality of human existence to understand how we’ve survived to this moment in time.”He explained that we can use evidence of how humans lived in the past – that was discovered by archaeologists – to understand how we could be impacted by climate change and potentially move through it. As technology continues to advance and assume a leading role in archaeology, Mr Redfern believes that humans will always be needed to provide real value to discoveries. He said: “Technology has had a profound impact on archaeological thoughts and processes. That is not slowing down but the beauty of it is you will always need a human to translate that. “It’s the human who scribes the value to objects. Whatever you do, it will always come back to what relevance that has to us as human beings.”

Ancient shipwreck ‘frozen in time’ leaves archaeologists stunned: ‘Doors eerily open’
‘Very special’ Isle of Man treasure hoard solves 1,100-year-old Viking mystery
Ancient Greece treasure trove stunned researchers: ‘Nothing like it found in a century’
Some of the most significant archaeological finds to have ever been made have come from the British Isles. In 2009, 4,500 fragments of war gear and religious objects were discovered that were later found to date back to the seventh century.The haul was dubbed the Staffordshire Hoard and in total amounted to 4kg of gold and 1.5kg of silver. In 2001, a metal detectorist discovered what would become known as the Ringlemere Cup. At more than 3,500 years old the artefact helped to shed light on what it would have been like to live in that point of history and is now on show at the British Museum.

PART-2: CRITICAL COMMENTARY: ABSTRACT: THAT ARCHAEOLOGISTS DISCOVERED ANCIENT CLIMATE CHANGE BEFORE HUMANS STARTED BURNING FOSSIL FUELS IS NOT MORE REASON TO TAKE CLIMATE ACTION; IT IS LESS REASON TO TAKE CLIMATE ACTION; BECAUSE NOW WE KNOW THAT THESE THINGS HAPPEN NATURALLY ANYWAY INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION OR NO INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION.

IN RELATED POSTS WE ARGUE THAT THE CLIMATE CHANGE ISSUE OF OUR TIME IS NOT THAT CLIMATE CHANGE CAN HAVE HARMFUL IMPACTS BUT THE USE OF THOSE IMPACTS TO PUSH AN ANTI FOSSIL FUEL AGENDA AT GREAT COST TO SOCIETY AND THAT THE WEAKER THE EVIDENCE OF HUMAN CAUSE THE GREATER THE FEAR APPEAL ACTIVISM NEEDS TO BE.

The transition between late antiquity and the early medieval period in  north Etruria (400-900 AD) - Medievalists.net

RELATED POSTS#1: THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF HOLOCENE CLIMATE CHANGE EVENTS OF THE PAST ARE DESCRIBED.

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/10/05/a-quora-question-3/

RELATED POST#2: THE CLIMATE CHANGE ISSUE OF OUR TIME IS NOT WHETHER CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS CAN BE HARMFUL. THE ESSENCE OF THE CLIMATE MOVEMENT IS NOT THAT IT IS WARMING NOR THAT THE WARMING CAN HAVE HARMFUL IMPACTS, THE ESSENCE OF THE MOVEMENT IS THE HUMAN CAUSE HYPOTHESIS THAT SERVES AS THE BASIS FOR THE DEMAND FOR THE COSTLY CLIMATE ACTION OF MOVING THE WORLD’S ENERGY INFRASTRUCURE FROM FOSSIL FUELS TO RENEWABLES.

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/09/the-issue-is-human-cause/

EXTRACT-1

THE ONLY ISSUE IS HUMAN CAUSE

EXTRACT -2:

Medieval Europe: An Extract from Chris WickhamYale University Press London  Blog

Ancient Roman architecture - Wikipedia

BOTTOM LINE

THAT ARCHAEOLOGISTS DISCOVERED ANCIENT CLIMATE THAT HAPPENED BEFORE HUMANS STARTED BURNING FOSSIL FUELS IS NOT MORE REASON TO TAKE CLIMATE ACTION; IT IS LESS REASON TO TAKE CLIMATE ACTION; BECAUSE NOW WE KNOW THAT THESE THINGS HAPPEN NATURALLY ANYWAY INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION OR NO INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION.

THE INTENT HERE IS OF COURSE, OH LOOK HOW HORRIFIC THE CLIMATE IMPACTS CAN BE AND SO YOU SHOULD HEED WHAT WE SAY AND TAKE CLIMATE ACTION.

EXCEPT THAT WITHOUT HUMAN CAUSE THERE IS NO RATIONALE FOR CLIMATE ACTION.

QUESTION

Aside from climate change driven by the greenhouse effect of the atmosphere, can geological heat from underneath the Earth’s crust in any way emit enough heat to the surface to cause warming?

ANSWER

The Paleo data show many examples of global warming and climate change as creations of the Earth’s own geological events. The Mid Miocene warming and the Paleocene Eocene Thermal Maximum are two notable examples where the earth warmed itself with its own geological forces.

LINKS TO CITED POSTS

#1: MID MIOCENE WARMING: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2019/01/17/miocene/

miocene-hominoids

#2: PALEOCENE EOCENE THERMAL MAXIMUM: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/03/20/an-atmosphere-bias-part-2/

PETM-BIOTA

A SUMMARY OF THE ATMOSPHERE BIAS ISSUE

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/23/summary-of-the-atmosphere-bias-issue/

ABSTRACT:

WE PROPOSE THAT THE THEORY OF ANTHROPOGENIC GLOBAL WARMING AND CLIMATE CHANGE IS VERY SPECIFICALLY AN ATMOSPHERIC ISSUE WHERE THE THEORY IS THAT HUMANS BURNING FOSSIL FUELS INCREASE ATMOSPHERIC CO2 CONCENTRATION AND THAT THE GREENHOUSE EFFECT OF CO2 IMPLIES THAT RISING ATMOSPHERIC CO2 CONCENTRATION CREATES RISING GLOBAL MEAN SURFACE TEMPERATURE (GMST) AND THAT RISING GMST IS UNDERSTOOD AS GLOBAL WARMING. THIS THEORY FROM TOP TO BOTTOM IS A PURELY ATMOSPHERIC PHENOMENON. THE ATMOSPHERE BIAS ISSUE IN THIS CONTEXT IS THE INTERPRETATATION OF THIS PHENOMENON IN TERMS OF THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN SITUATIONS WHERE A ROLE OF THE ATMOSPHERE IS NOT POSSIBLE.

THIS POST IS A PRESENTATION OF A MEDIA ALARM ABOUT HOW HOT IT IS IN THE ARCTIC.

LINK TO SOURCE: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/12/14/un-confirms-record-artic-temperature

PART-1: WHAT THE MEDIA IS SAYING

UN confirms record 38C temperature for the Arctic. The Siberian town of Verkhoyansk reached a temperature of 38C during a prolonged heatwave in June last year (2020). The WMO has confirmed that a temperature of 38C reached in a Siberian town last year was a record for the Arctic.The WMO says that the high temperature that hit Verkhoyansk on June 20, 2020, came during a prolonged heatwave amid conditions which averaged as much as 10C above normal for much of the summer over Arctic Siberia. This new Arctic record is one of a series of observations … that sound the alarm bells about our changing climate. Verkhoyansk is about 115km north of the Arctic Circle. It is a region that is among the fastest warming in the world and is heating at more than twice the global average warming rate. The WMO says that the 2020 heatwave fuelled devastating fires, drove massive sea loss and played a major role in last year being one of the three hottest years on record and therefore it is likely that greater extremes will occur in the Arctic region in the future. The WMO has opened a record number of investigations into weather extremes as climate change unleashes unrivalled storms and heatwaves. Since Arctic records are a new category, the data for the Verkhoyansk probe needed checking against other records as part of a vigorous verification process involving a network of volunteers. The record is now an official entry in the World Weather & Climate Extremes Archive. Last year also saw a new temperature record for the Antarctic continent of 18.3C at Argentina’s Esperanza station, while a WMO committee is also verifying other potential heat records, including in Death Valley in California in 2020. The organisation is also seeking to validate a reported record for Europe in Italy’s Sicily, which saw the thermometer climb to 48.8C this summer. The WMO Archive of Weather and Climate Extremes has never had so many ongoing simultaneous investigations.

PART-2: CRITICAL COMMENTARY

LOCALIZED TEMPERATURE EVENTS ON OUR EARTH ARE NORMAL AND UNDERSTOOD IN CLIMATE SCIENCE AS INTERNAL CLIMATE VARIABILITY AND NOT SOME KIND OF CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACT ANOMALY. LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/07/16/the-internal-variability-issue/ . HOWEVER, IT IS POSSIBLE THAT AN INTERGLACIAL GLOBAL WARMING CYCLE MAY INCREASE THE FREQUENCY AND SEVERITY OF THESE EVENTS.

AS FOR EXAMPLE, IN THE PREVIOUS INTERGLACIAL, THE EEMIAN, A SEVERE GLOBAL WARMING CYCLE HAD CAUSED AN UNUSUAL AND INTENSE LOCALIZED TEMPERATURE EVENT IN THE ANTARCTIC THAT HAD CAUSED THE WEST ANTARCTIC ICE SHEET TO COLLAPSE AND THAT IN TURN HAD CAUSED A CATASTROPHIC SEA LEVEL RISE OF SEVERAL METERS. IN CLIMATE SCIENCE THIS EEMIAN EVENT IS UNDERSTOOD AS A CREATION OF GLOBAL WARMING BUT IT WAS NOT HUMAN CAUSED.

THEREFORE THE TEMPERATURE EVENTS PRESENTED ABOVE MUST BE UNDERSTOOD AS INTERNAL CLIMATE VARIABILITY UNLESS IT CAN BE SHOWN THAT A COMPARISON OF THESE EVENTS AGAINST HISTORICAL DATA PROVIDES EVIDENCE THAT AN UNUSUAL SEVERITY OF THESE INTERNAL CLIMATE VARIABILITY EVENTS MAY HAVE BEEN A CREATION OF GLOBAL WARMING AS IN THE COLLAPSE OF THE WAIS DURING THE EEMIAN INTERGLACIAL. OTHER EXAMPLES OF UNUSUALLY SEVERE LOCALIZED HIGH TEMPERATURE EVENTS IN A PERIOD OF GLOBAL WARMING ARE ALSO FOUND IN THE HOLOCENE. IN THAT CONTEXT, THE GREATER ISSUE HERE IS NOT THAT THERE WERE HIGH TEMPERATURE EVENTS IN THE ARCTIC DURING THE CURRENT GLOBAL WARMING CYCLE OF THE HOLOCENE, NOR THAT THEIR SEVERITY COULD BE A CREATION OF GLOBAL WARMING BUT WHETHER HUMANS TAKING CLIMATE ACTION CAN MODERATE OR ELIMINATE THESE EVENTS – SOMETHING THAT CAN BE POSSIBLE ONLY IF THE CURRENT WARMING CYCLE OF THE HOLOCENE IS HUMAN CAUSED.

THEREFORE, THE REAL ISSUE HERE IS NOT THAT GLOBAL WARMING INCREASES THE FREQUENCY AND SEVERITY OF HIGH TEMPERATURE EVENTS BUT WHETHER THERE IS A ROLE FOR HUMANS IN THESE INTERGLACIAL TEMPERATURE DYNAMICS SUCH THAT HUMANS CAN MODERATE OR ELIMINATE SUCH HIGH TEMPERATURE EVENTS BY TAKING THE CLIMATE ACTION OF NOT BURNING FOSSIL FUELS AS DEMANDED BY CLIMATE SCIENCE.

AN UNDERLYING ASSUMPTION IN ENVRONMENTALISM IS THAT ALL BAD THINGS ARE HUMAN CAUSED AND CAN AND MUST BE MODERATED OR ELIMINATED BY CHANGING HUMAN BEHAVIOR. THIS ILLOGIC IS ALSO FOUND IN CLIMATE SCIENCE. A FURTHER ASSSESSMENT OF THIS ISSUE OF NATURAL VERSUS ANTHROPOGENIC GLOBAL WARMING IS PRESENTED IN A RELATED POST ON THIS SITE: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/09/the-issue-is-human-cause/

EXTRACT:

LINK TO SOURCE: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/12/13/opinion/climate-change-effects-countries.html

THE SOURCE DOCUMENT LINKED ABOVE LISTS A LARGE NUMBER OF COUNTRIES AND DESCRIBES THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF {GLOBAL WARMING / CLIMATE CHANGE} ON THESE COUNTRIES COUNTRY BY COUNTRY. THIS IS A VERY LONG LIST AND A SIGNIFICANT COMPILATION OF THE DETAILS OF CLIMATE IMPACTS THAT APPEAR TO BE ALL HARMFUL IMPACTS. MORE THAN HALF OF THE COUNTRIES IN THIS COMPILATION ARE LISTED BELOW IN THE GRAPHICAL FORMAT IN WHICH THEY WERE PRESENTED IN THE SOURCE DOCUMENT.

THE ESSENTIAL MESSAGE OF THE SOURCE ARTICLE IS THAT THE DETAILED LIST, COUNTRY BY COUNTRY, OF THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF GLOBAL WARMING PRESENTS A STRONG CASE FOR CLIMATE ACTION AND BASED ON THAT ARGUMENT, ALL THE COUNTRIES OF THE WORLD MUST LAY ASIDE THEIR DIFFERENCES AND COME TOGETHER FOR THE SAKE OF THEIR OWN SAFETY AND SURVIVAL AND TAKE THE COOPERATIVE GLOBAL CLIMATE ACTION OF ABANDONING FOSSIL FUELS GLOBALLY. THIS IS THE CLIMATE ACTION SOUGHT BY CLIMATE SCIENCE BECAUSE IT IS CLAIMED THAT SUCH A COOPERATIVE GLOBAL CLIMATE ACTION WILL STOP THE WARMING AND SAVE HUMANITY AND NATURE ITSELF FROM THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF GLOBAL WARMING LISTED IN THE SOURCE DOCUMENT AND IN THE IMAGES PRESENTED BELOW.

CRITICAL EVALUATION OF THE CASE FOR CLIMATE ACTION PRESENTED IN THESE IMAGES AND IN THE SOURCE DOCUMENT LINKED ABOVE.

THE ESSENCE OF THE CASE FOR CLIMATE ACTION IS THAT GLOBAL WARMING HAS HARMFUL IMPACTS ON HUMANS AND ON NATURE AND IT IS THEREFORE IMPERATIVE THAT WE TAKE CLIMATE ACTION TO RELIEVE NATURE AND THE CITIZENS OF THE LISTED COUNTRIES FROM THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF GLOBAL WARMING DESCRIBED IN THE LISTED IMAGES.

CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS

Fear Appeals A look at the rhetoric of climate change advertisements

WHAT WE FIND IN THE FEAR APPEAL LITERATURE LINK: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5789790/ IS THAT FEAR APPEAL STRATEGIES THAT ARE CLOSER TO HOME AND AT HIGHER LEVELS OF FEAR WORK BETTER THAN FEAR APPEAL STRATEGIES THAT ARE MORE GENERIC. WHAT WE ALSO FIND IN THE FEAR APPEAL RESEARCH PAPER LINKED ABOVE IS THAT GRAPHIC DISPLAYS ENHANCE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF FEAR APPEAL.

THE GRAPHIC DISPLAYS PRESENTED HERE OF THINGS TO FEAR IN THE CLIMATE CHANGE MOVEMENT AGAINST FOSSIL FUELS IS BEST UNDERSTOOD IN TERMS OF THE FEAR APPEAL STRATEGY OF CLIMATE SCIENCE DESCRIBED IN RELATED POSTS ON THIS SITE LINKED BELOW:

LINK#1: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/07/22/fear-appeal-in-climate-change/

LINK#2: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/29/fear-appeal-bibiography/

GRAPHIC DISPLAY OF CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS COUNTRY BY COUNTRY

TURKEY


CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS

Fear Appeals A look at the rhetoric of climate change advertisements

WHAT WE FIND IN THE FEAR APPEAL LITERATURE LINK: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5789790/ IS THAT FEAR APPEAL STRATEGIES THAT ARE CLOSER TO HOME AND AT HIGHER LEVELS OF FEAR WORK BETTER THAN FEAR APPEAL STRATEGIES THAT ARE MORE GENERIC. WHAT W ALSO FIND IN THE FEAR APPEAL RESEARCH PAPER LINKED ABOVE IS THAT GRAPHIC DISPLAYS ENHANCE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF FEAR APPEAL.

THE GRAPHIC DISPLAYS ABOVE OF THINGS TO FEAR IN THE CLIMATE CHANGE MOVEMENT AGAINST FOSSIL FUELS IS BEST UNDERSTOOD IN TERMS OF THE FEAR APPEAL STRATEGY OF CLIMATE SCIENCE DESCRIBED IN RELATED POSTS ON THIS SITE LINKED BELOW:

LINK#1: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/07/22/fear-appeal-in-climate-change/

LINK#2: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/29/fear-appeal-bibiography/

THE USE OF GRAPHICAL DISPLAYS IN THE FEAR APPEAL STRATEGY FOR CLIMATE ACTION AND THE COUNTRY BY COUNTRY PRESENTATION OF THESE FEARS IS BEST UNDERSTOOD IN TERMS OF THE FEAR APPEAL THEORY PRESENTED IN THE NCBI/NIH RESEARCH PAPER LINKED ABOVE.

Fear Appeals A look at the rhetoric of climate change advertisements

Archana Boyda now provides farmers with compost from her cows.

LINK TO SOURCE: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/dec/12/cyclones-people-bangladesh-climate-catastrophe-guardian-observer-charity-appeal

IT IS REPORTED THAT ANTHROPOGENIC GLOBAL WARMING CLIMATE CHANGE HAS UNLEASHED TROPICAL CYCLONE HORROR IN BANGLADESH AND THE SUFFERING OF THESE MISERABLE PEOPLE SHOULD SERVE AS A MORAL OBLIGATION TO TAKE CLIMATE ACTION AND STOP BURNING FOSSIL FUELS. DETAILS IN THE SAMPLE MEDIA ARTICLE PRESENTED BELOW.

SAMPLE MEDIA ARTICLE ABOUT THE HORROR THAT GLOBAL WARMING HAS UNLEASHED ON BANGLADESH.

We faced so many cyclones’: how people in Bangladesh are rebuilding after climate catastrophe
Archana Boyda now provides farmers with compost from her cows. Archana Boyda now provides farmers with compost from her cows. Photograph: Kamil Ahmed/The Observer. This year’s Guardian and Observer campaign supports charities fighting global climate injustice. Here, we look at Practical Action, which helps small farms in Bangladesh. The cyclones that repeatedly hit his village deep in Bangladesh’s south did not just bring waist-high water that washed everything away, they forced Shayma Kanta Mistri to make a choice about his future.The salt waters that had surged in from the nearby Bay of Bengal ruined his paddy fields, which were already providing only a tenuous living that had to be supplemented by seasonal labouring for other farmers. Mistri needed to adapt or leave. Everywhere in Shyamnagar, there are signs of people refusing to just accept that climate change will force them to move. This is the most south-western part of Satkhira district and one of the areas in Bangladesh most vulnerable to the climate crisis. Rice fields have been turned into ponds by owners who realise their land will not easily recover and so have begun farming crab and shrimp. People are fighting back to avoid the fate of thousands of others, who have had to leave for overcrowded cities, broken by the effects of global heating on their land and their lives. “We faced so many cyclones and they brought waters that came up to here on the street,” said Mistri, holding his hand at waist level. “When the waters left it was like a desert, all the plants and trees were dying from the salt and there was no clear water to drink. There were only a few people with money who could survive these conditions.“We could not live from farming any longer. We had to think about other ways to make our living.” Satkhira and the south-west have borne the brunt of the weather changes, repeatedly being hit by major cyclones that have displaced millions and caused permanent changes to the land. During last year’s cyclone Amphan winds hit 151kmph and flooded a quarter of Satkhira. Two-thirds of migrants from south-western Bangladesh moved because they had to give up farming. Most went to cities where they worked as day labourers. AJM Shafiqul Islam, said the charity’s work is about ensuring people are offered the most suitable solution and support to help build their resilience to the climate crisis. Since cyclone Sidr [in 2007], the people of this area have struggled with salinity in their soil but these methods are transforming lives. Gabura, an island encircled by two rivers of the Sundarbans mangrove forest, is frequently inundated during cyclones and is losing its coast to erosion. Locals live in fragile homes mounted on stilts. These farmers look to wild sources like the river or the Sunderbans, which is vulnerable environmentally and needs to be protected. Archana has been living in a leaking mud hut. It has been destroyed by a falling tree during cyclone Amphan. Amphan had a really big effect. Houses were destroyed and people had nowhere to go.

CRITICAL COMMENTARY

ITEM#1: THE CLIMATE SCIENCE OF THE IMPACT OF GLOBAL WARMING ON TROPICAL CYCLONES.

According to climate science, the impact of global warming on tropical cyclone activity can be found only in long term (30 years or more) changes in global tropical cyclone activity when all tropical cyclones in all six cyclone basins for the entire study period are included in the study. Specifically, a single tropical cyclone in a single cyclone basin has no interpretation in terms of global warming or climate change.

LINK TO RELATED POST: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/01/30/list-of-posts-on-tropical-cyclones/

WE ALSO NOTE THAT CYCLONE AMPHAN, BEING PRESENTED HERE TO PROMOTE THE CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACT ON TROPICAL CYLONES, IS RELATIVELY MILD WHEN COMPARED WITH THE HORRIFIC DESTRUCTION AND DEATH TOLL OF THE CALCUTTA CYCLONE OF 1737.

THAT CYCLONE HAD OCCURRED NOT IN A TIME OF GLOBAL WARMING BUT IN A TIME OF GLOBAL COOLING DURING THE LITTLE ICE AGE.

The Little Ice Age

RELATED POST ON THE LITTLE ICE AGE: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2018/07/19/liaclimatologybibliography/

lia4

These kinds of climate activism in the media implies either that the media promoting the climate science case against fossil fuels does not actually understand what this case is; or that climate science is actually not science but anti fossil fuel activism that uses the appeal to science for credibility. However, as we see in this example, the case against fossil fuels presented by climate science is not credible.

ITEM#2:

THE USE IN THIS WAY BY THE GLOBAL NORTH OF THE POVERTY AND MISERY OF THE GLOBAL SOUTH THAT HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE CREATION OF ANTHROPOGENIC GLOBAL WARMING BY THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION OF THE GLOBAL NORTH, TO SELL THE CLIMATE ACTION PRIORITY OF THE GLOBAL NORTH IS A GROTESQUE AND RACIST EXAMPLE OF HOW THE ESSENTIAL IDEA OF COLONIALISM, THAT THE GLOBAL SOUTH MUST ULTIMATELY SERVE THE NEEDS OF THE GLOBAL NORTH, HAS SURVIVED INTO THE MODERN WORLD IN THE FORM OF THE CLIMATE CHANGE MOVEMENT.

QUESTION#1: WHAT ARE SOME THREATS TO CORAL REEFS?

ANSWER: For hundreds of millions of years we have had coral reefs, through glaciation cycles and through many many interglacial warming and cooling cycles. And the coral are still here. I don’t think they need pesky little humans to worry about them and to take care of them but maybe they need the pesky little humans to tone down their ego and their bizarre self image as managers of nature and of the planet itself.

QUESTION#2: WHAT MAJOR CITIES IN THE UNITED STATES HAVE MADE EFFORTS TO GO GREEN LIKE THEIR EUROPEAN COUNTERPARTS?

ANSWER:

The green European cities are Stockholm, Hamburg, Vitoria Gastiez, Nantes, Copenhagen, Bristol, Ljubljana, Essen.

The best European cities to live in are Vienna, Zurich, Munich, Dusseldorf, Frankfurt, Copenhagen, Geneva
Basel
.
Maybe no incentive here for US cities to copy the green European cities.

QUESTION: What are incentives for countries to lead in climate change?

ANSWER: There are neither incentives not a rationale for countries to lead in climate change. The only issue is global fossil fuel emissions and the only solution is a globally coordinated program to reduce global fossil fuel emissions. There is no role here for climate heroism of nation states. PLEASE SEE

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/02/23/renewable-energy-statistics/

QUESTION:

How come most people acknowledge that climate change is happening, but act in an unsustainable, consumption driven manner?

ANSWER: Climate change is natural and these kinds of warming and cooling cycles are the norm. The climate change issue of our time is not whether climate change is HAPPENING. The only issue is whether, this time around, it is human caused. LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/09/the-issue-is-human-cause/

10 questions with answers in CLIMATE CONTROL | Science topic

THIS POST IS A CRITICAL REVIEW OF MEDIA REPORTS THAT CLIMATE CHANGE ISN’T DONE DESTROYING CORAL REEFS AND THAT THE REEFS IN THE WESTERN INDIAN OCEAN HAVE BEEN TARGETED FOR DESTRUCTION.

LINK TO SOURCE: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/dec/06/all-coral-reefs-in-western-indian-ocean-at-high-risk-of-collapse-next-50-years-global-heating-aoe

PART-1: WHAT THE SOURCE ARTICLE SAYS

All coral reefs in western Indian Ocean ‘at high risk of collapse in next 50 years. Reefs from Seychelles to South Africa may become functionally extinct due to global heating and overfishing, study finds. Corals
off Mayotte, between Madagascar and Tanzania are bleached and that island reefs are threatened with destruction as water temperatures rise. This is the age of extinction. These extensive reef systems from Seychelles to Delagoa are at risk of becoming functionally extinct by the 2070s. Biodiversity will be lost. Hundreds of thousands of people will lose their food sources and livelyhoods with island nations particularly threatened. Reefs in Madagascar, the Comoros and Mascarene Islands are critically endangered. Reefs in island nations are HIGHLY threatened. The problem is rising water temperatures driven by global heating and the heating in turn causes coral bleaching when the coral expels its algae and turns white.

IT GOES ON AND ON WITH THE HORRORS OF CORAL BLEACHING BUT WHAT WE PRESENT ABOVE IS THE ESSENTIAL MESSAGE

Coral reefs of western Indian Ocean at risk of collapse: study- The New  Indian Express

PART-2: CRITICAL COMMENTARY

THE ESSENCE OF THE ARGUMENT HERE IS HUMAN CAUSE MEANING THAT THE CORALS ARE BEING DAMAGED BY GLOBAL WARMING AND THE GLOBAL WARMING IS CAUSED BY HUMANS AND SO THEREFORE THE CORALS ARE BEING DAMAGED BY THE HUMANS AND SO THEREFORE THE HUMANS CAN AND MUST SAVE THE CORAL FROM THE HORROR OF GLOBAL WARMING BLEACHING DESCRIBED SIMPLY BY TAKING CLIMATE ACTION AND THAT IMPLIES THAT WE MUST STOP BURNING FOSSIL FUELS.

HOWEVER, ALTHOUGH A LONG AND DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE HORROR OF GLOBAL WARMING FOR THE CORAL REEFS IS DESCRIBED IN GREAT DETAIL NO EVIDENCE IS PROVIDED AND NONE EXISTS THAT THE WARMING IS CAUSED BY HUMANS. WARMING AND COOLING CYCLES IN INTERGLACIALS ARE THE NORM AND NOT AN ANOMALY THAT REQUIRES EXPLANATION IN TERMS OF HUMAN CAUSE. WHAT’S MORE, THAT THE CURRENT WARMING CYCLE OF THE HOLOCENE HAPPENED TO BE PRECEDED BY THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION IS NOT EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE OF CAUSATION.

THAT WE ARE IN A PERIOD OF GLOBAL WARMING AND THAT GLOBAL WARMING CAN HAVE HARMFUL IMPACTS ON NATURE ARE NOT THE ISSUE BECAUSE THEY DON’T IMPLY THE CLIMATE ACTION BEING DEMANDED BY THESE ARGUMENTS. THE GLOBAL WARMING ISSUE IS NOT THAT IT IS WARMING AND NOT THAT WARMING CAN HAVE HARMFUL IMPACTS. THE ONLY ISSUE IS HUMAN CAUSE AND WITHOUT EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE OF HUMAN CAUSE THERE IS NO BOTTOM LINE TO THESE SAD TALES OF THE HARMFUL IMPACTS OF GLOBAL WARMING EXCEPT THE OBSERVATION THAT NATURE CAN BE CRUEL AND OFTEN IS.

RELATED POST ON THE HUMAN CAUSE ISSUE: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/09/the-issue-is-human-cause/

EXTRACT

LINK TO THE DETAILS: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/09/the-issue-is-human-cause/

Worst global coral bleaching event eases, as experts await next one | Coral  | The Guardian

ENHANCED HEAVY EQUIPMENT TRANSPORTER SYSTEM (EHETS) - USAASC

Aaron Hilliard - Quora
AARON HILLIARD

QUESTION

What will future heavy equipment from public construction and military vehicles run on if fossil fuels are abolished?

Heavy Duty Construction Equipment Parked At Work Site Stock Photo, Picture  And Royalty Free Image. Image 30080196.

MY ANSWER:

Climate science says the future is all electric even heavy construction equipment and heavy military equipment.

Heavy Equipment Transporter (HET) | KBR

In their words

In the next 20 years, it’s possible that all the backhoes, excavators, dozers, graders, and other heavy equipment we use on construction sites will move away from diesel engines to all-electric. All we have to do is to develop the needed technology and save the planet.

Staying Safe Around Heavy Equipment | Travelers Insurance

SO LET US ALL GET SERIOUS AND SAVE THE PLANET

How To Save The Planet

RELATED POST ON HOW TO SAVE PLANETS

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/09/25/planetary-environmentalism/

EXCERPT

THE MAN WHO DESTROYED THE OBAMA MYTHOLOGY IS OUT TO DESTROY THE COVID MYTHOLOGY

THIS POST IS A PRESENTATION OF A JACK CASHILL PAPER ON THE COVID PANDEMIC WITH THE TITLE: {THE CRACKPOTS WERE RIGHT. COVID IS A RACKET}.

LINK TO SOURCE: https://www.wnd.com/2021/12/crackpots-right-covid-racket/

RELATED POST ON ELITE CONSENSUS POLITICS: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/03/07/how-the-elite-subvert-democracy/

WHAT IS SAYS ON THE INTERNET IF YOU GOOGLE “COVID SYMPTOMS”

COVID-19 affects different people in different ways. Most infected people will develop mild to moderate illness and recover without hospitalization.

Most common symptoms: fever, cough, tiredness, loss of taste or smell,

Less common symptoms: sore throat, headache, aches and pains, diarrhoea, a rash on skin, or discolouration of fingers or toes, red or irritated eyes

WHAT JACK CASHILL SAYS: The crackpots were right: COVID is a racket:

I confess to having seen Big Health’s actions as merely misguided. I was wrong. The “crackpots” were right. The Big Health involvement did not progress along the Eric Hoffer spectrum from a good cause to a movement with benefits to a racket. It started as a racket, a massive racket that may go down as a Mao-worthy crime against humanity.

Robert F. Kennedy”s dissection of Big Health’s war is this century’s must-read book. Here is an excerpt. It is a conversation of two scientists, Dr. Tess Lawrie, a world-renowned data researcher from the U.K. with an international reputation for integrity, and World Health Organization researcher Dr. Andrew Hill, a senior visiting research fellow at Liverpool University.

Lawrie and 20 of the world’s leading experts had recently performed a meta-analysis of the research done on ivermectin (IVM), and the data overwhelmingly supported its value in treating COVID-19. Andrew Hill had been an IVM proponent before making a suspicious about-face. His hasty counter-thesis blocked a worldwide ivermectin rollout. Hill explained that he was in a “tricky position” because his sponsors were pressuring him, the most important of which was Unitaid. Chairing the executive committee of Unitaid, an international quasi-governmental consortium, was the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation representative. Bill Gates ahd donated $150 million to Unitaid and that is what may have changed their position on IVM.


“There are a lot of different opinions about this,” Hill waffles. Lawrie cuts him off. “You don’t have to say, well, so-and-so says this, and so-and-so says that. It’s absolutely crystal clear. We can save lives today if we can get the government to buy ivermectin.” When Hill reverts to his “some people” argument, Lawrie counters, “We are looking at the data. It doesn’t matter what some people say.” Lawrie explains Hill’s “tricky position” to him. “I appreciate you are in a sensitive position if you are being paid for something and you’re being told to support a certain position.” She then lays out the only acceptable moral response: “So maybe you need to say, I’m not going to be paid for this. I can see the evidence.”

One can understand how an apparatchik could buckle before a Stalin or a Hitler, but a Bill Gates? When Hill protests that the NIH would not agree to recommend IVM, Lawrie shoots back, “Yeah, because the NIH is owned by the vaccine lobby.” Hill cannot deny Lawrie’s claim. “That’s not something I know about,” he said. Lawrie’s reply: “all I’m saying is this smacks of corruption, and you’re being played.” Hill’s response: “I don’t think so.” When pressed, Hill admits that Unitaid “has a say” in his research. Lawrie then asks for a name of someone at Unitaid. Hill will not oblige her and continues to waffle, “I mean this is very difficult because I’m, you know, I’ve got this role where I’m supposed to produce this paper and we’re in a very difficult, delicate balance. Lawrie denies him his “I was just following orders” alibi. “So this will come out, and you will be culpable. And I don’t understand why you don’t see that.” Lawrie does not shy from telling Hill what he refuses to see: “All other countries are getting ivermectin except the U.K. and the USA and Europe are owned by the vaccine lobby.” Lawrie concludes by telling Hill, “I don’t understand how you sleep at night, honestly.”

Donald Rumsfeld’s True Cause Of Death Is No Secret Anymore. As the Kennedy book documents, the racket runs deep. When I googled Lawrie’s name the first item to show up was a BBC article headlined, “Ivermectin: How false science created a Covid ‘miracle’ drug.” When I googled Dr. Andrew Hill, the first article Google served up was this gem from the Guardian, “How my ivermectin research led to Twitter death threats.” If it takes a crackpot to think that Big Pharma, Big Health, Big Tech, Big Media and Bill Gates would engage in a conspiracy so vast and so lethal, well then color me a “crackpot.”

More on Cashill’s view on how intellectuals hijack America Jack, see “Hoodwinked. This work may be found at http://www.Cashill.com.

THE BOTTOM LINE AND THE SHORT ANSWER TO ALL OF THIS IS WHAT IS CALLED “ELITE CONSENSUS POLITICS”. THIS MODE IS ALSO FOUND IN THE CLIMATE CHANGE MOVEMENT AND IS DESCRIBED IN A RELATED POST ON THIS SITE.

RELATED POST ON ELITE CONSENSUS POLITICS: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/03/07/how-the-elite-subvert-democracy/

RELATED POST ON COVID VACCINATION EMERGENCY: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/10/04/about-the-covid-vaccination-emergency/

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is image-14.png

THE ESSSENTIAL ELEMENT IN THIS LOGIC IS THAT TO QUESTION ELITE CONSENSUS IS SUICIDAL.

Ocasio-Cortez: No 'middle ground' on fighting climate change
TRAPPED BY ELITE CONSENSUS

RELATED POST: THE GREAT RESET

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/12/09/the-great-reset/

THE ALEX BERENSON ARTICLE ONLINE: LINK: https://www.dailysignal.com/2021/12/03/the-facts-about-covid-19-the-legacy-media-wont-tell-you/

DR AFSHINE EMRANI, HEART SPECIALIST ON THE OMICRON.

OMICRON IS LITERALLY THE VACCINE THAT THE VACCINE COMPANIES COULD NOT MAKE. IT IS ATTENUATED. NO HOSPITALIZATION REQUIRED. NO NEED FOR THE CRITICAL PATIENT STATUS. OXYGENATION OR INCUBATION NOT REQUIRED. EVERYONE WILL BE EXPOSED AND WILL GET IT. THE RESULT WILL BE HERD IMMUNITY. IT TOTALLY REPLACES DELTA. WITHIN 12 WEEKS THE WORLD WILL BE VACCINATED BY OMICRON. THERE IS NO NEED FOR AN OMICRON PANIC. IT IS NATURE’S VACCINE.

IAN PLIMER IS PROFESSOR EMERITUS OF EARTH SCIENCES AND AUTHOR OF THE BOOKS {GREEN MURDER} AND {HEAVEN AND EARTH GLOBAL WARMING THE MISSING SCIENCE}.

THIS POST IS A STUDY OF THE IAN PLIMER ASSESSMENT OF CLIMATE SCIENCE AS SUMMARIZED IN THE ARTICLE LINKED BELOW.

LINK TO SOURCE: https://politicom.com.au/climate-scientists-admit-to-lying-cheating-fraud/?fbclid=IwAR0Klq_B4Y65aC6zjWxBq4Zb_rMT3Fdkcx-VjebtI1s0S2aFWhNC-wasPC0

Professor Ian Plimer book launch - Not For Greens - YouTube

PART-1: WHAT THE IAN PLIMER ARTICLE SAYS

ACCORDING to green activists, climate change policies don’t need to be costed because they’re a moral issue. Do green activists have a household budget? Whether it’s their own money or that of taxpayers, there has to be fiscal responsibility. Climate “scientists” operate as green activists who admit they cheat, lie, commit fraud, change measurements, make false predictions, refuse normal scientific discussion and prevent the publishing of alternative data.


Climate change predictions are based on computer models that have consistently failed. What is touted today as “progressive” is in reality a regressive drift back to the Dark Ages. Green activists are able to get away with murder because they are unchallenged. The first moral issue is that climate activists ignore the evidence of the totality of integrated Earth systems and of history. They refuse to debate, they do not analyse data, resort to fraud, do not consider the consequences of their policies and they don’t really care about the damage their policies create.

FUTILITY: The second real moral issue is their futility trying to engineer a climate within a narrow range having no understanding of the impact to the environment to the diversity of flora and fauna and to the damage of so many Western countries. This damage is treated as mere detritus on the path to salvation. Taxpayer-funded climate “scientists” operate as green activists who admit they cheat, lie, commit fraud, change measurements, make false predictions, refuse normal scientific discussion and prevent the publishing of alternative data and conclusions.This is the seed of the whole corrupt climate change business.

Their antics are not expensive amusement but the destruction of the 2500 year-old scientific method which is a way of finding a truth. Climate “scientists” remain unchallenged by a fawning scientifically illiterate politicised media. For hundreds of thousands of years, humans and other organisms have adapted and flourished to great and rapid natural climate changes. Surely adaptation by an advanced technological society would be easier.

Climate change predictions are based on computer models that have consistently failed over the past 40 years when compared with the reality of actual measurements. The end result of changing the whole energy system based on this nonsense is an energy crisis. During the time I was writing my book Green Murder, the coal price rose 100 per cent and LNG price 500 per cent. Don’t tell me that fossil fuels are on the path to extinction. They are needed for survival.

The new green religion is a doomsday cult where the naïve and gullible seek salvation through the veneration of cruciform wind turbines and “settled science” that has replaced Scripture as the new religion. Fire and brimstone preachers cancel, de-platform and abuse those who question green dogma with all the savagery that was used by the Spanish inquisitors to root out heretics. What is touted today as “progressive” is in reality a regressive drift back to the Dark Ages with its misery, poverty and ignorance. {RELATED POST: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/10/11/anthropogenic-global-warming-in-a-post-modern-world/ }

The greens are not a soft cuddly feel-good political movement trying to make the planet a better place. Their green propaganda appeals to many of the young and well off. It is a communist-inspired destructive hypocritical western movement that destroys democracy and cares not for the environment. By their actions and consequences, greens kill people. There is nothing virtuous or admirable about being green.

With wind and solar electricity, someone always loses. These are the people on struggle street who cannot afford to pay the increasing electricity costs, especially when they face long-term unemployment as a result of COVID-19 virus lockdowns. It is immoral, unnecessary, futile and anti-human. There is a move now from European socialists, the UN and COP participants that the freedom losses experienced with COVID-19 lockdowns should be extended and that all citizens should have a climate passport where every atom of carbon used will be on a register to be monitored and taxed. This is communism. Cui bono.

Net-zero is a mindless meaningless slogan. It is undefined. What exactly is net-zero? What do we use? What don’t we use? Where is the due diligence? If it means no fossil fuel use then we go back 200 hundred years. We’ve been there. Endless mud, dung, shortened lives, disease, no heating, no cooling, nothing of the modern world and no hope.

Some EU leaders are telling us that under net-zero we will own nothing and be happy. I call this communist slavery. We’ve been there before and it all failed at great cost. Net-zero has no costings and you can bet your bottom dollar, because that’s all you’ll have left, that your money will make the green billionaires even wealthier. Net-zero is a cooked-up recipe for economic and social chaos, class division and further destruction of the west and its values. RELATED POST: LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/03/the-net-zero-fallacy/

The collapse in the values of Western civilisation is a far greater threat than climate change or China. There is no need for a Chinese invasion or war, we are destroying and enslaving ourselves from within.In just one year, parts of the West have collapsed into an energy crisis of their own making. This is a window into net-zero. If such facts offend you, so be it. Take a daily teaspoon of cement to harden up, broaden your knowledge, reduce your biases and challenge your thinking. My book Green Murder contains facts underpinned by repeatable validated evidence and the scientific method. No matter how offended you might be, feelings are not evidence.

Green activists are able to get away with murder because they are unchallenged. Certa Bonum Certamen {FIGHT THE GOOD FIGHT}. Don’t let them get away with it. In this book I charge the greens with murder. They murder humans who are kept in eternal poverty without coal-fired electricity.

Green Murder -- Ian Plimer

PART-2: CRITICAL COMMENTARY

THE RELIGIOUS NATURE OF THE GREEN ECO WACKO MOVEMENT IS SOMETHING WE STRONGLY AGREE WITH AND SOMETHIING WE HAVE PRESENTED IN RELATED POSTS LINKED BELOW:

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/10/11/anthropogenic-global-warming-in-a-post-modern-world/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/22/tiimothy-morton-dark-ecology/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/27/unnatural-humans/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/02/15/divine-environmentalism/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/06/13/the-climate-religion/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/10/21/climate-change-and-religion/

The Religion of Climate Change - The Global Warming Policy Forum

THE FUNDAMENTAL IAN PLIMER HYPOTHESIS THAT THE CLIMATE MOVEMENT IS REALLY AN ACTIVISM MOVEMENT AND THAT THE CLIMATE CHANGE ISSUE IS JUST SOMETHING THAT THE MOVEMENT NEEDED IS SUPPORTED IN RELATED POSTS WHERE WE PRESENT THE CASE THAT THE MOVEMENT IS BEST UNDERSTOOD AS ANTI FOSSIL FUEL ACTIVISM

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/03/23/anti-fossil-fuel-activism-disguised-as-climate-science/

A CONTENTIOUS ISSUE IS THE IAM PLIMER ARGUMENTS AGAINST “NET ZERO”. IN RELATED POSTS WE SHOW THAT THE CLIMATE ACTION DEMANDED BY CLIMATE SCIENCE IS NOT “NET ZERO FOSSIL FUEL EMISSIONS” BUT “ZERO FOSSIL FUEL EMISSIONS”. THE NET ZERO PROPOSAL IS THAT FOSSIL FUEL EMISSIONS ARE POSSIBLE IF THEY ARE OFFSET WITH INVESTMENTS IN CARBON CYCLE INTERVENTIONS THAT WOULD REMOVE AN EQUIVALENT AMOUNT OF CO2 FROM THE ATMOSPHERE. THIS CLIMATE ACTION PROPOSAL DOES NOT COME FROM CLIMATE SCIENCE. IT IS A CORRUPTION OF THE CLIMATE SCIENCE DEMAND FOR ZERO FOSSIL FUEL EMISSIONS.

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/03/the-net-zero-fallacy/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/02/25/net-zero/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/20/the-power-of-trees/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2019/09/30/cer/

Professor Ian Plimer book launch - Not For Greens - YouTube

THE IAN PLIMER CASE AGAINST CLIMATE SCIENCE THAT IT IS ACTIVISM AND NOT SCIENCE IS SUPPORTED IN RELATED POSTS WHERE WE PROVIDE SOME DETAILS OF THIS ISSUE.

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/04/13/the-science-of-climate-science-is-fear/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/01/the-fear-of-ignorance-derives-from-the-null-hypothesis-issue-in-climate-science/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/29/fear-appeal-bibiography/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/07/22/fear-appeal-in-climate-change/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/09/02/an-obsessive-fear-of-carbon/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/09/20/our-inner-need-to-fear/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/04/13/the-science-of-climate-science-is-fear/

Professor Ian Plimer book launch - Not For Greens - YouTube

SOME DETAILS OF THE GENERALIZED ASSESSMENT BY PLIMER OF WEAKNESSES IN THE SCIENCE OF CLIMATE SCIENCE ARE PROVIDED IN RELATED POSTS.

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/05/18/climate-science-vs-statistics/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2019/07/28/rcb/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2020/08/26/a-mathematical-inconsistency/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/18/tcre-transient-climate-response-to-cumulative-emissions/

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/11/09/the-issue-is-human-cause/

Professor Ian Plimer book launch - Not For Greens - YouTube

THE ELITE CONSENSUS POLITICS ISSUE IN CLIMATE SCIENCE

LINK: https://tambonthongchai.com/2021/03/07/how-the-elite-subvert-democracy/

Amazon.com: Climate Change: A Threat to All Life on Earth (End of Life as  We Know It) (9780766072848): Cunningham, Anne C, Green, Kenneth Philip:  Books